Job Creation Requires a Multitude of Approaches, Not Simply Relying on the Fed
Posted July 31, 2012 at 3:00 pm, in Allied Approaches
Appearing before Congress, Fed Chair Ben Bernacke predicted that the economy would not improve unless Congress addressed looming spending cuts and the expected increase in taxes. In response, Senator Charles Schumer of New York said that because Congress was unable to act it was the Fed’s job to stimulate the economy. Therefore, the Fed should get to work. And yet it is this passing the buck that is really the problem. For too long Congress and the White House have relied on the Fed to stimulate the economy through monetarism because it effectively absolves the political institutions of responsibility that typically accompanies fiscal policy. Still, each approach by itself is limited, and what is needed is the two together along with another tool, an incomes policy.
Monetary policy is essentially a bottom down approach that assumes that if interest rates can be lowered enough, investment will be stimulated and jobs created. All the Fed can do at the moment is get more money into the economy either through lowering interest rates again and more quantitative easing. Interest rates are already at their lowest level in years, and so far to little effect. The problem with the monetary approach is that it rests on faulty assumptions. Pumping more money into the economy, in and of itself, will not create jobs. Job creation requires a more grassroots approach. In order for there to be jobs creation, there needs to be aggregate demand for goods and services. Therefore, it matters not how much interest rates are lowered. If there is insufficient aggregate demand because individuals lack the financial wherewithal to demand goods and services, nothing is going to happen. To a certain extent, fiscal policy can help in this regard. By lowering taxes, individuals will have more money in their hands and will be able to demand more. But the current debate about extending the Bush era tax cuts is not really a serious discussion of fiscal policy. Extending the tax cuts is not the same as putting more money in people’s pockets; rather it simply prevents more money from being taken out of people’s pockets. What is needed is lowering taxes in conjunction with monetary policy, which would also require serious tax reform. But this too isn’t enough. (more…)










